It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Different genres.
And different art style by the way.

Both very, very good on their own merits, both spawned so many more similar games.

If you like RPG's in general, you should play both. But hey cannot be compared.

Don't know if there is anything else to say on this matter.
avatar
Zolgar: If you'd like to reproduce the flavour of tabletop role-playing, complete with a DM who is out to kill you repeatedly, you should try BG.
avatar
BreathingMeat: Ha! Imagining BG as a jerky DM:

DM: OK the actress suddenly turns into a witch and attacks you! Roll initiative!
Player: *rolls* I got 12.
DM: The witch initiated combat so she gets a surprise round. She casts a spell on you. *rolls* *rolls* *rolls* You take 25 points damage.
Player: What the balls? I'm only level 1! I've got, like, eight hit points!
DM: Well then you're DEAD! I win, lewzor! *fap* *fap* You got completely owned! *fap*
Player: This is bullshit.
DM: You shouldn't have taken the bodyguarding job. You need to be at least level 4 to do that quest. Ha! *fap* I completely wasted you! *fap*
Player: How was I supposed to know that?
DM: *fap* I can't hear you, Dead Mouth! *fap* *fap* *fap*
Player: This sucks arse. OK I'll try again from before I took the job.
DM: What? You're dead. You can't do anything! That's your guy there all over the cobblestones and the walls! *fap* On, like, minus seventeen hit points! You're going to need to roll up a new character.
Player: Yeah, but I saved. Remember when I said "I save"? So now I load from there.
DM: What is this? You can't "save" and "load"!
Player: Either I load from before I took the job, or I leave your stale-smelling basement and spend the rest of my evening with my girlfriend.
DM: No, you have to roll up a new character. But I'll be kind: I'll let you start in Beregost. Even though it completely ruins the integrity of the story.
Player: You have man-boobs; Amy has girl-boobs. Good night, Duncan.
DM: OK fine, you can "load". Cheater.
Or you could of just paused to gain initive, and then used imeons magic missle or xzars ldrain to disrupt the lightninig bolt.. monty can move in for a back stab by that time anyway.. .. : )




Diablo is great fun, but you cant really compare the two games
Baldur's Gate isn't turn-based, for those who keep saying it is.
I don't understand why anyone would compare the two. It would be more useful to compare BG to Torment, or the Icewind Dale series, or even Fallout for that matter.
It's pretty much a question of

Longterm satisfaction vs Instant gratification.

What I mean by this is, in Baldur's Gate you hop in and you are slowly immersed into the world and you have a complex tactical combat system and a deep story, and even though you're not really smiling the whole way through,you're satisfied when you take down a huge boss or when you reach the conclusion of the epic story.


In Diablo you can just hop in and have some fun immediately - you don't need to be familiar with any rules or prerequisites - it's just mindless fun.
avatar
cryptomundo: Baldur's Gate isn't turn-based, for those who keep saying it is.
You can make it practically turn based. If you make it pause at the end of every round, it feels like Fallout.
Post edited November 01, 2010 by Dori34543
I remember having a conversation with a game shop clerk about RPGs. And I remember this bit. "I didn't liked Baldur's Gate because there was nothing the that wasn't already done in Diablo." Which lead me to think that he didn't play much.