I killed Saerk and his daughter as revenge and the Order of the Radiant Heart kicked Amonen. Should i kick him from the party? Will he cause trouble?

Also is it possible his allegiance changed from True neutral to chaotic neutral

Edit sorry i mislicked i wanted to post it on Baldur's Gate forum
Please delete

If Anomen gets kicked from the Order, his alignment does shift to Chaotic Neutral. If you helped him to pass his knight training, he would have shifted to Lawful Good (and he gains 4 points of Wisdom).

The Chaotic Neutral version of Anomen will have potential conflicts with Keldorn and Aerie -- if you have either of them in your party with Anomen, they may start fighting. If you're playing a "good" character he will criticize your actions but won't actually come to blows with you.

If you're playing a low-to-medium reputation party, you can keep Anomen around but Viconia would probably be a better choice since Anomen only has 12 Wisdom, which is pretty low for a cleric. He becomes a much stronger character if he becomes knighted and gains the extra 4 points of Wisdom.

Yes you should kick him unless you really don't want Viccy and she is hands down the better Cleric so he only has the extra combat skills

I replaced him with Keldorn do you think he's a good character to have?

While I haven't used an Inquisitor myself, everything I've read about them indicates it is a solid class. Be aware that Keldorn will eventually come to blows with both Viconia and Failed Anomen if you have them along, and as a paladin he won't allow/accept certain things (like continuing to hold the noble lady for the ransom).

So it boils down to your party composition and how you intend to play.

Yes, Keldorn is a strong support character, though not too deep.

And aside what Bookworm627 said, at least in the OS, he doesn't do anything against Viconia. Heck, I doubt in BG2-ToB any partymember would do anything against other partymembers aside quareling. the only problem can be reputation with evil partymembers around as far as I'm aware of..

Keldorn's weapon of choice is likely twohanded swords (top being Carsomyr), and his dispel and true sight comes in very handy. Aside that, he's a moderatlystrong melee combatant.

And yes, if you're going to get the Silver Pantaloons, put Keldorn out of the group for the duration of that quest, else he won't let you (he'll say you were only joking, and the questline gets cutted there and then).

They will fight to the death if they travel together for too long. There are quite a few characters in BG2 who will do that and you can only have them both together via cheating.

Sometimes Gambashee and other guides is not the most reliable source.
I've actualy played with Viconia and Keldorn both in the party, and never had any trouble, thank you.
Well, due to alignment-reasons I've frequently kicked out Viconia - just to rehire immediately - from the party of course.

https://baldursgate.fandom.com/wiki/Viconia_DeVir
"She will eventually come to blows with Keldorn if left in the same party for too long."


https://baldursgate.fandom.com/wiki/Keldorn_Firecam
Read the comments...

https://forums.beamdog.com/discussion/70633/viconia-and-keldorn-how-likly-are-they-going-to-kill-each-other

As stated, the only way to keep both Viconia and Keldorn in the party is either by using a mod or using some tactics mentioned in the last link like keeping them apart. Otherwise, they WILL fight. That's how it is scripted and it happened to me too. I love Viconia ;)

Aaand your link is irrelevant to what I've said.
I said THE ORIGINAL game, while your link (3rd) is about EE.

Also, I've mentioned, I've frequently kicked out Viconia from the party, and I bet that's "keeping them separate" (likely that action nullifies their time together).

They also fight each other in the original BG2.

I repeat: they never did for me. And the reason for that might be me kicking out Viconia regularly to avoid reputation-problems.

I gave you 3 links, the first 2 is for both. And I already told you my own experience for the originals.

You generally have a habit of claiming things as facts and try to correct others and give advice even tho they are utterly wrong. You might be using mods, experienced a bug, or like you say keep them apart. It does NOT matter. The game has a script and their relation is iconically scripted that way. Please do at least some basic google search before spearing these false informations.